We asked ChatGPT and Perplexity for the best GEO agencies. They barely agreed.
We asked ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini which agencies help brands get recommended by AI. The lists barely overlapped, and the sources they used explain why.
We asked ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini which agencies help brands get recommended by AI. The lists barely overlapped, and the sources they used explain why.
Rank on Google
Blue links, snippets and maps — and the base layer AI reads from.
Named by assistants
Cited in the answers ChatGPT, Perplexity and Copilot give.
Synthesised by AI
The source Google AI Overviews and Gemini build their answer from.
One shared foundation: crawlable, structured, trustworthy content — run as a single program.
If a buyer asks an AI assistant to name the best GEO or AEO agency, which companies come back? We ran the test on 31 October 2026. We asked ChatGPT and Perplexity the same kind of question a buyer would, and looked at what Google surfaces for it. The short version: the engines almost never named the same companies, and a lot of what they read is agencies ranking themselves.
The headline finding
Across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google, only three agencies showed up again and again: iPullRank, Siege Media and Omniscient Digital. Everyone else changed from engine to engine, and even from one phrasing of the question to another.
No tricks. We asked plain buyer questions in a normal browser:
We ran these in Perplexity and in ChatGPT (with web search on), and we looked at Google's results for the same queries. We recorded the company names each one returned. Results move over time and by phrasing, so treat this as a snapshot, not a league table.
Perplexity gave a different shortlist for almost every phrasing:
| Question | Companies Perplexity named |
|---|---|
| best GEO agencies | iPullRank, Go Fish Digital, Omniscient Digital, Siege Media, Seer Interactive |
| best AEO agencies | iPullRank, Optimist, Omniscient Digital, Zupo, Fire&Spark, Thrive |
| get recommended by ChatGPT | MaximusLabs, Clickslice, Clearbrand, Awrange, Contensify, DerivateX |
ChatGPT, asked for the best GEO/AEO agencies with web search on, named a different set again, split into India-based and international:
| Region | Companies ChatGPT named |
|---|---|
| India | Nakama Growth, Unveilr, Qoulomb, TripleDart, Social Beat, Infidigit, Techmagnate |
| International | iPullRank, Siege Media, Omniscient Digital, First Page Sage, NoGood, Avenue Z |
Google, for the same searches, mostly returned "best agencies" listicles: Thrive, iPullRank, Siege Media, First Page Sage, Ten Speed, SEO Discovery, PageTraffic, Searchbloom, Digital Elevator, GrowPad and more.
Put the two AI engines side by side and the overlap is tiny. Only iPullRank, Siege Media and Omniscient Digital appeared on both. Perplexity leaned toward established US content and PR agencies; ChatGPT surfaced a mix of Indian specialists and US names that Perplexity never mentioned. If you were a buyer, the "best agency" would depend entirely on which assistant you happened to open.
On Perplexity, "best GEO agencies" and "which agencies get you recommended by ChatGPT" produced two completely separate lists, with zero companies in common. One phrasing pulled established SEO agencies; the other pulled a newer set of AI-visibility specialists. There is no single ranking to win. You have to own a category of questions, not one keyword.
This is the uncomfortable part. A large share of the pages Google and the AI engines read are listicles published by agencies that rank themselves at the top. In our snapshot, Thrive's list put Thrive first (98/100), Ten Speed's list put Ten Speed first, and GrowPad, DigiMark and Digital Elevator each led their own lists. The AI engines are aware of this: ChatGPT noted that one India list was published by the agency it ranked first, so "its first-place position isn't independent validation," and Perplexity flagged self-published evidence too.
Self-ranked listicles are cheap to make, which is why everyone makes them. As more of them appear, both readers and AI tools discount them. Treat them as table stakes, not an edge.
The three names that recurred across engines, iPullRank, Siege Media and Omniscient Digital, did not get there by publishing more blog posts. They share the signals AI trusts:
Both ChatGPT and Perplexity added, unprompted, that no agency can guarantee a ChatGPT recommendation, because answers vary by prompt, geography, context and time. ChatGPT's own buying advice was blunt: don't pay an agency just to publish 30 blogs, 20 backlinks and 10 press releases, because that is not necessarily GEO. Anyone promising "#1 in ChatGPT" is overselling.
The test lines up with how these systems actually work. There are three jobs, and they are not the same:
Publishing more of your own content helps discoverability and ranking, but it will not, on its own, get you recommended. The levers that move the needle are mostly off your own site: get named by others, publish original data, keep your brand entity consistent, and make your claims easy to quote.
Where Edthi stands (honest version)
We should say it plainly: Edthi did not appear in any of these answers. We're a new AI Visibility company, and the three jobs above are exactly what we run for clients and are now building for ourselves, in this order: open AI-crawler access (done), a consistent brand entity, original research like this piece, and independent third-party authority. This study is both our method and our starting baseline. We'll re-run it and show the change.
We repeated the test on 5 November with ChatGPT (search on) and Gemini, and this time asked each to list its sources. ChatGPT named iPullRank, First Page Sage, Siege Media, Intero Digital, Omniscient Digital, Amsive, WebFX, Go Fish Digital, SmartSites and Signal Hill Strategies. Gemini named iPullRank, First Page Sage, Directive Consulting and Stratabeat. Only two names appeared in both.
The sources were the more useful part. ChatGPT built its list from Clutch, an index of GEO agencies, a review-research site, two agency comparison reports and a directory of AI agencies. Gemini used two "best GEO agencies" articles and an industry publication. Neither used an agency's own website. Edthi was not named by either.
The fastest way to act on this is to see where you actually appear right now across Google and the AI engines. Explore AI Visibility, book a 30-minute call at cal.com/edthi-meet/30min, or message us on WhatsApp at +31 6 47553735. We'll show you your baseline and the plan to become the answer, and we won't promise you a number we can't control.
AI Visibility specialist at Edthi · SEO, AEO & GEO
Leads AI Visibility programs at Edthi, helping companies get found and recommended across Google and the AI engines. Writes about how AI search actually decides who to cite.
Ready when you are.
Book a 30-minute call, message us on WhatsApp, or drop your details and we'll reach out. We'll show you where you show up today across Google and the AI engines — and the plan to become the answer.
How to measure share of voice in AI answers: a practical guide
AI Visibility (SEO · AEO · GEO)How AI search decides which sources to cite
AI Visibility (SEO · AEO · GEO)How to get recommended by AI, not just found
AI Visibility (SEO · AEO · GEO)Why choose Edthi for AI visibility (SEO, AEO & GEO)